I have managed to scan the Legg report, and there are quite a few Rebels who have paid back only part, or none of what Legg has requested back.
I reckon the number tops over 10% of all surveyed, and over 20% of those asked to pay back. Strangely, there is a large number of MP's who have paid back more than asked, sometimes by a ridiculous variance that raises new questions.
Here are the rebels, I will refresh as I update. Page reference is as per the .pdf page, as viewed here - in case you want to go see what the report states.
Margaret Beckett - P. 37. Gardening Claims exceeded maximum allowance by £2,539.75 between 2006 & 2008.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £2,539.75
Amount Outstanding - £2,539.75
Nick Brown (Chief Whip) - P43. Over claimed for a cleaner. Total Cost claimed was £8,697.65 over the four-year period which exceeded the maximum allowable claim level by £697.65. This must be embarrassing for the Gordon Brown as he can't send the Whip after wrongdoers, if the Whip himself is rebelling!
Legg Recommended Repayment - £697.65
Amount Outstanding - £697.65
Gregory Campbell - P.47 Lot's of wrong claims here.
Overpaid by £741 on hotel stays between October 2004 & March 2006
Overpaid by £1,456.54 on service charges
Overpaid by £458.56 on ground Rent
No Documents to support claims for £1,017.28 for mortgage interest in December 2008 which Legg must then regard as invalid and the whole sum subject to repayment.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £3,673.38
Amount Outstanding - £3,673.38
Paul Clark - P.50.
Paid £549.95 for a new washing machine which exceeded the guideline price by £164.95
In default of evidence to support mortage interest payments totalling £11,750.35 for 2008-09.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £11,915.30
Repaid - £508.43
Amount Outstanding - £11,406.87
Show us the receipts Paul!
Nadine Dorries - P. 61.
Paid £882.31 twice for same hotel expenses in January 2007
Paid £161.04 twice for Internet service in April 2007
Paid £271.02 twice for telephone bill in 2008-09.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £1,314.37
Amount Outstanding - £1,314.37
Don't make US ask twice for the money back!
Barbara Follett - P. 67
Paid £34,776.30 between April 2004 and November 2008 for mobile security patrols at her Second Home. This exceeds the Green Books remit of 'Basis Security Measures'
Paid £8,908.36 for SIX phone lines for the second house. Deemed excessive and half the amount of £4.454.18 marked for repayment.
Overpaid by £2,812.95 in 2004-05 and 2006-07 for additional household premium for fine art, which is not allowable.
Paid £221 twice for boiler insurance in 2004.
Paid £193.78 for pest control in 2006 against an address other than her second home.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £42,458.21
Paid - £32,976.17
Amount Outstanding - £9,482.04
Have hubby pay for the additional personal security and make do like the rest of us! - Clearly a top trougher.
Don Foster - P. 68
In 2005 took out an additional second mortgage against his second home for a purpose not allowed under the ACA. As a result he was overpaid by £3,557.02.
Overpaid £193.72 in April - June 2007 on mortgage interest.
Paid £525 twice in £2008-09 for mortgage and term valuation fees.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £4,275.74
Amount Outstanding - £4,275.74
Edward Garnier - P.70
Paid £1,920 for Gardening in 2005-06, which exceeds annual allowance by £920
Overpaid by a total of £301.68 for rent in 2006-07 and 2008-09 periods.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £1,221.68
Amount Outstanding - £1,221.68
Andrew George - P.71
Paid £1,397.34 twice for hotel costs in May 2005
Overpaid by a total of £159.44 for food in 2004-05 & 2005-06.
Overpaid by £694.44 for Council Tax in 2008-09.
Overpaid by £1,695.12 for mortgage interest in 2008-09 as two monthly claims were duplicated.
Overpaid by £168.08 in 2008-09 for duplicate payments of telephone & electricity costs.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £4.348.25
Paid - £3,160.41
Amount Outstanding - £1,178.84
That's a lot of duplicate claims!
Mike Hall - P. 76
Paid £10,364.28 over four years for laundry, dry cleaning and ironing services. This exceeds the £2,000 annual limit by £2,364.28.
Paid himself £250 Petty Cash out of ACA allowance - Not allowable in Green Book.
Also paid £250 for incidental expenses in September & October 2004; such expenses not allowed under the Green Book.
Paid £8,789 for 'household sundries' without providing any receipts.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £12,639.28
Amount Outstanding - £12,639.28
Pay it back you troughing git!
David Hamilton - P. 77
Overpiad for mortgage interest over five years totalling £2,595.51
Legg Recommended Repayment - £2,595.51
Amount Outstanding - £2,595.51
David Heathcoat-Amory - P79
Paid for cleaning costs of £12,995.35 over 5 years. Exceeding £2,000 annual limit by £2,995.35.
Paid £30,696.58 for Gardening over 4 year period. This exceeds the £1,000 annual limit by £26,696.58.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £29,691.93
Paid - £6,122.24
Amount Outstanding - £23,569.69
Pay it back, then cut your own lawn and wash your own clothes as we ain;t paying nay more!
Geoff Hoon - P. 83
Overpaid by £1,013.13 on mortgage interest.
Paid £138.29 for gas bill twice.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £1,151.42
Paid - £383.76
Amount Outstanding - £767.66
Pay it back you utter, utter Hoon.
Dr Kim Howells – P.85
Overpaid by £665.11 for mortgage interest between 2006 & 2009.
Overpaid by £288 for a gas bill in 2008-09
Legg Recommended Repayment - £953.11
Paid - £294
Amount Outstanding - £659.11
Huw Irranca-Davies - P. 87
Overpaid by £2,008.19 for mortgage interest over 5 years.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £2,008.19
Amount Outstanding - £2,008.19
Dr Lynne Jones – P. 89
Paid £815 twice for heating and radiator repairs in July and August 2005.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £815
Amount Outstanding - £815
Eric Joyce – P. 90
Overpaid by £5,002.56 for mortgage interest between 2004-05 and 2007-08.
Paid twice for a £3,000 claim for mortgage interest in November and December 2007
Also paid twice in the same period for council tax, cleaning and service/maintenance claims totalling £600.
Legg Recommended Repayment - £8,605.56
Amount Outstanding - £8,605.56
Alan Keen – P. 91
Alan claimed £1,790 for a cleaner in 2006-07. However, Alans wife, Ann Keen is also an MP and she claimed £1,000 for a cleaner at the same time and address. Thus, there is a £790amount in excess of the allowable limit to be split between the two of them.
Legg Repayment Request - £345
Amount Outstanding - £345
Ruth Kelly – P. 92
Overpaid by a total of £441.47 in mortgage interest for the years 2004-05, 2006-07 & 2008-09.
She was paid £476.39 twice for her February 2008 mortgage interest claim.
Claimed £157.90 in 2008-09 for newspapers which is not allowed under the ACA.
She was paid £631.58 in November 2008 for mortgage arrears relating back to 2003 which is not a permissible claim.
Legg Repayment Request - £1,707.34
Amount Outstanding - £1,707.34
Jim Knight – P. 94
Overpaid by £223.50 incorrectly in April 2005 after incorrectly calculated around dissolution.
He was overpaid by a total of £2,657.11 for mortgage interest between 2007-08 and 2008-09.
Claimed for a computer costing £571.06 which should not have been claimed via the ACA.
Legg Repayment Request - £3,451.67
Paid - £1,256.84
Amount Outstanding - £2,185.83
Jacqui Lait – P. 95
Overpaid by £622.94 for mortgage interest in the years 2007 & 2008.
Has not provided sufficient evidence for claims made in the period January to March 2009 which it is therefore recommended it be repaid in full.
Legg Repayment Request - £1,041.59
Paid - £87.67
Amount Outstanding - £953.92
Tom Levitt – P. 97
Overpaid by a total of £800.95 between April 2004 and March 2006 on mortgage interest.
Claimed £1,599 for a sofabed which exceeds the relevant guideline price by of £1,210 by £389.
Legg Repayment Request - £1,189.95
Paid - £412.00
Amount Outstanding - £777.95
No point asking if you sleep comfortably at night; your guests clearly do.
Sir Michael Lord – P. 99
Paid £8,784.76 for gardening costs between march 2005 and January 2009 which exceeds the maximum allowable limit by £4,874.76.
Overpaid by £289.72 on mortgage interest for two time periods.
Legg Repayment Request - £5,074.48
Amount Outstanding - £5,074.48